Best Exotic Pet Insurance Companies 2025: Who Covers What?

If you own a dog, you have 20+ insurance companies to choose from. If you own a Cockatoo or an Iguana, your list is… short.

Here is the landscape of Exotic Pet Insurance in 2025.

🥇 The Heavyweight: Nationwide (Avian & Exotic Plans)

Nationwide (formerly VPI) pioneered exotic coverage and holds 90%+ of the market share.

The Good

• Acceptance: They take almost anything. Birds, reptiles, small mammals, even some marsupials (Sugar Gliders) and amphibians.
• Coverage: The “Whole Pet” plan (if available) covers accidents, illnesses, exams, labs, X-rays, and prescriptions.
• History: They know what “Egg Binding” is. You won’t have to explain it to the adjuster.

The Bad

• Enrollment System: You often have to call to enroll (1-800 number) rather than a slick AI app.
• Price: Not dirt cheap, but reasonable ($10-$40/mo).
• Age Limits: Strict cutoffs. Do not wait until your pet is old.

🥈 The Alternatives

1. Pet Assure (Discount Plan)

• What it is: NOT insurance. It is a discount card.
• How it works: You pay a monthly fee, and participating vets give you 25% off medical services.
• Pros: No pre-existing condition exclusions. accepted by many exotic vets.
• Cons: Only 25% off. A $4,000 surgery still costs you $3,000.

2. Wells Fargo Health Advantage / CareCredit

• What it is: Financing / Credit Cards.
• Pros: Allows you to pay over time (often 0% interest for 6-12 months).
• Cons: You still pay the full amount eventually.

🔮 Future Trends?

We are watching companies like MetLife and ASPCA, who have hinted at expanding into the exotic space. But as of 2026, Nationwide remains the only true “Comprehensive” player.

📋 Checklist Before You Buy

1. Check Your Vet: Does your exotic vet accept/work with Nationwide? (Most do).
2. Call for Quote: Prices vary wildly by zip code and species.
3. Read the “Benefit Schedule”: Ensure you are getting a “Percent of Invoice” plan, not a capped “Benefit Schedule” plan if possible.

Summary Verdict

• For Catastrophic Protection: Get Nationwide.
• For Pre-Existing Conditions: Get Pet Assure.
• For Cash Flow Mgmt: Get CareCredit.

Related Articles

• Exotic Pet Insurance Guide
• Is Rabbit Insurance Worth It?
• Parrot Insurance Guide